Leading Discussions Groups
presented by Suzanne Le-May Sheffield
at the OIDT TA Teaching Workshop "Running Discussion Groups" October 3, 2002

factual questions that are important and are stated clearly in the text

questions that ask the student to figure out the authors main point

'what if' questions

imaginative questions (if you were in this situation...)

questions that help students to contextualize the material within the larger framework of the course

questions that relate the day's material to material read on previous days.

 

Escaping Some of the Pitfalls of the Discussion Group

Discussion Leadership can be challenging, but in some ways it feels safe. You are in control of the discussion, you don't have to move from your seat and you may even be able to chose who speaks and who doesn't.

However, to engage students in more active learning try to break away from the led discussion, or simply use it less frequently. Students will then be able to take responsibility for their own learning, and this can take the pressure off of you to provide all the answers.

Having students work individually, in pairs or in groups will allow you to give a safe space to the quiet student, suppress to some degree the talkative students, and allow peer pressure to work in your favour for getting the reading done. Students often feel more pressure to get the work done if they know that their peers are relying on them to come prepared, than if they know they only have to worry about you.

Give students a role in the group, and if you use group-work frequently make sure they swap roles - leader, record-keeper, reporter, gate-keeper, encourager, harmonizer, energizer.

Listen to what the different groups are talking about, notice silent groups and try to help them get started, don't impose yourself into a group so that you are once again the discussion leader, only for the smaller group.

 

Ideas to get Started:

1. Small group work varieties:

A. pairs work - think/pair/share

B. group work - various sizes

C. debate

2. Have the students make up questions - before class, during class.

3. Come to class with discussion questions and break the class into groups and have them address the question(s) - have them report back to the class.

4. Make up case studies, or problems to solve, or scenarios. Have students work through these exercises in groups.

5. Brainstorm on a particular issue - in small groups or in the larger group with the tutorial leader writing on the board.

6. Silent preparation work. At the beginning of class have the students spend five minutes thinking about a particular question, or trying to solve a particular problem by themselves. This will allow students to reflect on what they read for the class and to direct their attention towards it. Then move on to class discussion or group work..

Back to Teaching Tips       CLT Home